Canonical commentaryFrom a canonical standpoint
Procedural concerns
The synodal decision of 22 May 2025 was adopted by a vote of ten in favour and six against. Metropolitan Tychikos and his legal team argue that individual charges were not examined as separate proceedings, and that the composition of the investigative committee does not conform to the sacred canons.
The matter of confession
At the heart of the case are the refusal of concelebration with the OCU, public stances against communion with Roman Catholicism, and opposition to mandatory sex education. All positions rest on theological and canonical foundations.
Appeal and the Phanar
The Synod of the Ecumenical Patriarchate, while acknowledging procedural irregularities, upheld the deposition "for the sake of ecclesiastical peace" on 17 October 2025. Many canonists consider this decision erroneous: the peace of the Church is not achieved by the sacrifice of canonical order.
Full canonical analysis by professors of canon law is in preparation. This is a preliminary presentation of the three key issues.